7 Newsletter Mistakes That Hurt Engagement and Inbox Placement (and How to Fix Them)

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

Putting a lot of effort into creating a newsletter, but not seeing significant results? Your click-through and reply rates are consistently low. This is a common situation that almost every creator has experienced. In this article, we’ll look at the typical mistakes made in email newsletters that hurt engagement and inbox placement. These issues are easy to overlook, but they may be the reason your email marketing is struggling. Let’s dive in.

7 Newsletter Mistakes to Fix Today

#1. Irrelevant content.

The quality of your newsletter content is above all other components. In a world where information flows from countless sources all at once, it can be tough to concentrate on one thing. This is often why subscribers never become engaged readers.

This usually happens for two reasons:

1) Your newsletter content doesn’t match your audience’s current interests;

2) The right content is sent to the wrong segment.

Both scenarios lead to passive behavior and low clicks, which mailbox providers interpret as weak engagement, decreasing your inbox placement.

How to fix:

• Inspect trending topics in your industry and present them in a concise, easy-to-scan format.
• Take the time to segment your email list into groups to define the best audience to send a newsletter to.
• When you’re ready with the target audience, study what kind of content they consume: follow influencers, competitors’ newsletters, and ask your subscribers directly through polls or short surveys on their interests and expectations.

#2. Heavy template.

Overdesigned HTML templates, heavy images, skipped mobile optimization, and overloading with links significantly reduce readability and chances of conversion, and can trigger spam filters, especially when combined with low engagement.

How to fix:

• Format your newsletter for a better user experience.
• Design a responsive, mobile-first email template.
• Focus on one main CTA, with a secondary hyperlink only if truly needed.
• Keep HTML code clean and accessible across different email clients.

With GlockApps, you can test not only inbox placement but also review your email’s content analysis: links, images, redirects, and HTML structure, all of which affect spam filtering and engagement.

#3. Overusing preview text with “read more” teasers.

When a newsletter contains only short snippets that push readers to “read more,” you’re adding friction. That extra step might seem small, but many subscribers won’t take it, leading to weaker interaction signals and overall dissatisfaction.

How to fix:

• Provide value already in your email newsletter.
• Share a concise version of your main article idea.
• Use links as optional extensions, not mandatory steps.

#4. Not tracking or ignoring key performance metrics.

Metrics in email marketing are super important. Customers who interacted recently are much more likely to engage again, and mailbox providers closely watch these signals, forming their opinion about your reputation as a sender. Inactive subscribers quietly drag your score down.

How to fix:

• Watch key metrics (open trends, click-through and reply rates, spam complaints, unsubscribes, bounces, inbox/spam placement rates, and spam filter scores).
• Regularly remove inactive subscribers.
• Review subject line performance to spot those that generate more clicks or replies.
• Segment by engagement level and send less frequently to passive users.
• Focus on quality interactions, not list size.

#5. A strong sales-pitch feeling.

If your content sounds overly promotional, the recipient will quickly sense this and simply close your email. People want to connect with real people. Let your readers know that a real person is behind your newsletter. When every message pushes a demo, discount, or call booking, recipients disengage. Even the best content won’t perform if it’s introduced with overly salesy subject lines.

How to fix:

• Share opinions, insights, or practical tips without pressure.
• Even if a campaign includes a sales goal, lead with value first.
• Keep a healthy balance of promotional content and educational/entertaining content.

#6. Inconsistent sending patterns.

Everyone likes consistency. If you promise a weekly newsletter when they subscribe, but send it only once a month, this mismatches with their expectations, which will eventually lead to decreased engagement and unsubscribes. Long gaps followed by sudden spikes in sending may cause mailbox providers to see unstable behavior and filter your newsletter as spam.

How to fix:

• Clearly state the frequency of your newsletter (weekly, biweekly, or monthly) on the signup page and stick to your promise.
• Keep a predictable schedule to build a reputation as a trusted brand among users and providers.

#7. Skipping spam testing before sending.

Sending without checking for spam? That’s a huge mistake. Your efforts may be wasted because providers today employ sophisticated algorithms to check emails and often send legitimate messages to spam folders, meaning that your subscribers will not even be able to read what you have worked so hard to create and send.

How to fix:

• Run spam tests with GlockApps before every send to see how your newsletter lands across major global ISPs.
• Review spam filter results, content warnings, and authentication checks.
• Fix issues fast before they affect your newsletter campaigns.

Conclusion

Newsletters are not just for selling. Their purpose is to deliver value to the reader. Strong content, human-centric approach, clean design, predictable sending habits, solid email authentication, and regular spam testing all work together to make your newsletter successful. When subscribers interact with your emails, mailbox providers take notice. Focus on fixing the mistakes that hurt engagement first, and deliverability will follow naturally. 

FAQ